Podcast Logo
Podcast Logo

Intriguing, amusing, strange and significant stories from the history of science

Series 1: The Flat-Earth Incident

Part 1

At a socialist commune in East Anglia, Samuel Rowbotham takes advantage of the fenland landscape to develop an outlandish cosmological theory.

Part 1

At a socialist commune in East Anglia, Samuel Rowbotham takes advantage of the fenland landscape to develop an outlandish cosmological theory.

Part 2

Two flat earthers inspired by Samuel Rowbotham enter into a bizarre wager with an eminent naturalist.

Part 2

Two flat earthers inspired by Samuel Rowbotham enter into a bizarre wager with an eminent naturalist.

Part 3

Arguments over the result of the wager between John Hampden and Alfred Russel Wallace descend into a campaign of lawsuits and hate mail.

Part 3

Arguments over the result of the wager between John Hampden and Alfred Russel Wallace descend into a campaign of lawsuits and hate mail.

Images

Sources

Primary Sources

Parallax [Samuel Rowbotham] (1865). Zetetic Astronomy. Earth Not A Globe!. London: Simpkin, Marshall and Co. Pdf available from the Internet Archive

Common Sense [William Carpenter] (1866). Theoretical Astronomy Examined and Exposed. London: F. Pitman Full Text available from the Internet Archive

John Hampden (1869). The Popularity of Error and the Unpopularity of Truth. London: Simpkin, Marshall and Co. Pdf available from the Flat Earth Society

William Carpenter (1871). Water, Not Convex: The Earth Not a Globe!. London: William Carpenter Ebook available from Google Books

Alfred Russell Wallace (1905). My Life: A Record of Events and Opinions. London: Chapman and Hall Volume 1 and Volume 2 available from John van Wyhe, ed. 2002-. The Complete Work of Charles Darwin Online (darwin-online.org.uk)

Tryon [Samuel Rowbotham] (1845). An Inquiry into the Cause of Natural Death. Manchester: Abel Heywood Full Text available from the Wellcome Collection.

William Carpenter (1845). One Hundred Proofs that the Earth is not a Globe. Baltimore: William Carpenter Full Text available from Project Gutenberg.

Newspaper articles were mostly sourced from British Newspaper Archive.

Wallace's correspondence was mostly from John van Wyhe, ed. Wallace Online (wallace-online.org.uk)

Secondary Sources

Christine Garwood (2007). Flat Earth: The History of an Infamous Idea. London: Macmillan.

Bob Schadewald (2015), ed. Wendy Schadewald. The Plane Truth. Full Text available online.